Cast Iron Chicken with Buffalo Cottage Cheese Sauce Recipe

If you’re craving something flavorful, comforting, and a little bit spicy, you’re going to absolutely love this Cast Iron Chicken with Buffalo Cottage Cheese Sauce Recipe. It’s one of those dishes that feels fancy enough for guests but comes together super quickly on a weeknight. When I first tried it, I was amazed at how the creamy, tangy buffalo cottage cheese sauce pairs perfectly with crispy-seared chicken breasts, all cooked in one skillet for easy cleanup. Stick with me, and I’ll share everything you need to nail this favorite in your own kitchen!

Ingredients You’ll Need

The magic here really happens when simple ingredients come together in one pan. Every element—from the juicy chicken breasts to the sharp parmesan and tangy buffalo sauce—plays its part to make this dish sing. When shopping, grab fresh chicken breasts and your favorite buffalo sauce to customize the heat.

• Chicken Breasts: Make sure they’re fresh or fully thawed for even cooking; trimming excess fat helps too.
• Avocado Oil: I love avocado oil because it withstands high heat and adds a subtle, nutty flavor.
• Parmesan or Mozzarella Cheese: Either one melts beautifully—mozzarella for stretch and parmesan for sharpness.
• Cottage Cheese: The base of the sauce that brings creaminess without tons of fat; look for full-fat if you want richness.
• Buffalo Sauce: Pick your favorite brand, and adjust based on your heat tolerance—I usually add a little extra!
• Garlic Powder: Adds that warm depth without overwhelming fresh garlic’s bite.
• Salt and Pepper: Essential seasonings that bring everything to life.
• Optional Nutritional Yeast: Great for an extra cheesy, umami boost if you want a dairy-free twist or daring flavor upgrade.

Variations

This Cast Iron Chicken with Buffalo Cottage Cheese Sauce Recipe is super adaptable, which is one reason it’s become a go-to for me. I like to switch things up based on what’s in my fridge or my mood for the meal. Don’t be afraid to make it yours!

• Mild Version: I used to struggle with spicy foods, so I toned down the buffalo sauce with extra cottage cheese and a pinch of paprika for flavor without heat.
• Extra Cheesy: Adding a handful of shredded cheddar on top before baking really amps up the comfort factor — my family goes crazy for this cheesy twist.
• Vegan Inspired: Swap chicken for marinated tofu or cauliflower steaks and nutritional yeast in the sauce; it’s a surprisingly yummy plant-based alternative.
• Herby Boost: Fresh herbs like cilantro or parsley mixed in or sprinkled on top add a fresh brightness that balances the richness.

How to Make Cast Iron Chicken with Buffalo Cottage Cheese Sauce Recipe

Step 1: Season and Prep the Chicken

Start by patting your chicken breasts dry — this step is key for good browning. Season both sides generously with salt and pepper. While you’re prepping, go ahead and preheat your oven to 350°F. I like to do this early so it’s ready when the chicken hits the pan.

Step 2: Sear the Chicken in Your Cast Iron Skillet

Heat about a tablespoon of avocado oil over medium-high heat in your cast iron skillet. Once shimmering, add the chicken breasts. Let them cook undisturbed for about 5 minutes until you see a beautiful golden crust form—resist the urge to move them around! Flip carefully and cook the other side another 5 minutes. If your pan starts smoking, turn down the heat; you want a nice sear without burning.

Step 3: Whip Up the Buffalo Cottage Cheese Sauce

While your chicken is browning, toss cottage cheese, buffalo sauce, garlic powder, salt, pepper, and optional nutritional yeast into a blender or food processor. Blend until super smooth—this took me a bit to get right, but once it’s velvety, you’re set. Feel free to taste and adjust for more heat or seasoning here.

Step 4: Top and Bake to Finish

Spoon a generous tablespoon (or more if you love it!) of that buffalo cottage cheese sauce over each chicken breast right in the cast iron pan. Sprinkle shredded parmesan or mozzarella on top. Then pop the whole skillet into your preheated oven. Bake until the sauce bubbles and the chicken reaches an internal temperature of 165°F, around 10 minutes. I usually use an instant-read thermometer here to get it perfect every time.

Step 5: Serve and Enjoy!

Once out of the oven, let the chicken rest for a couple of minutes—you’ll find it juicier and easier to slice. Serve it with your favorite veggies or grains and enjoy the creamy, spicy goodness.

How to Serve Cast Iron Chicken with Buffalo Cottage Cheese Sauce Recipe

Garnishes

I love topping this dish with freshly chopped chives or green onions for a fresh pop of color and mild onion flavor. A sprinkle of extra parmesan or even a few blue cheese crumbles work wonders for an extra savory touch. Sometimes I drizzle a tiny bit more buffalo sauce if we want to turn up the heat at the table.

Side Dishes

My go-to sides with this cast iron chicken are steamed broccoli or roasted asparagus to keep things light and veggie-forward. Cauliflower rice is a personal favorite to soak up the sauce without adding heaviness. On cheat days, I serve it alongside creamy mashed potatoes or brown rice – comfort guaranteed!

Creative Ways to Present

If I’m serving this for guests, I like plating each chicken breast on a bed of bright green spinach or kale sautéed with garlic. For a fun twist, I even make mini versions using chicken tenders and bake them in a cast iron for a party platter. It’s always a hit—and super impressive.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

After cooking, I let the chicken cool completely before transferring to an airtight container. Stored in the fridge, it stays great for 3–4 days. The sauce keeps separately well for about 5 days, so I often scoop some onto salads or snacks later in the week.

Freezing

I’ve frozen this dish successfully by packing cooked chicken breasts and sauce separately in freezer-safe containers. When I thaw them, the sauce can sometimes separate a bit but a quick whisk and gentle warm-up restores the texture nicely.

Reheating

The best way I’ve found to reheat leftovers is in a 350°F oven until warmed through—about 15–20 minutes. This keeps the chicken juicy and the sauce creamy without drying out or burning like a microwave sometimes does.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

I absolutely love how this Cast Iron Chicken with Buffalo Cottage Cheese Sauce Recipe turns out every time—juicy, flavorful chicken topped with a sauce that’s creamy with a spicy kick. It’s one of those dishes that I’m excited to share because it’s approachable but feels like a special treat. Whether you’re cooking for yourself, family, or friends, this recipe will put a smile on everyone’s face. Give it a try next time you want comfort food with a punch—you won’t regret it!

Print